A farmer, hearing that a circus was in town, loaded his wagon with vegetables to sell there. He was excited; more than anything, he wanted to see an actual elephant. He got in town just in time to see the circus parade, led by an elephant. The farmer was thrilled, but his horses were terrified. Bolting, they overturned the wagon and ruined all the vegetables. “I don’t give a hang,” the farmer said, “for I have seen the elephant.”
This was a well-known story in the 19th Century. “To see the elephant” came to mean the culmination of long-held desires, to see what few have seen, to experience the adventure of the unknown in exotic places, to risk all and be content even if all was lost in the adventure of a life made more colorful, more vibrant and more exhilarating for launching into the deep.
To forty-niners and those following, no expression characterized the California Gold Rush better than “seeing the elephant.” Those bitten by the gold bug said they were “going to see the elephant.” Those who returned claimed they had seen the “elephant’s tracks” or the “elephant’s tail.” The elephant itself became a symbol of the Gold Rush, adorning miners’ stationery, books and posters.
The 1850 U.S. Census shows Seth Dunham, age 24, living with his family in Orland, Hancock County, Maine, when the census taker visited them there on August 25.1 He had been born in Orland on May 4, 1826, only six years after Maine was admitted as the 28th state.2 His father James, born in Orland about 1788, is listed as a farmer, as were most others in the area. James married Elizabeth “Betsy” Gilpatrick on March 25, 1814.3 She was born in Orland on May 27, 1795 and died about 1860.4 They apparently lived a relatively uneventful life, but Seth must already have been adventurous and anxious to see the world, for his occupation is listed as sailor. Shortly after the visit of the census recorder, he was off to see the elephant.
By April 9, 1851 (the 1850 census was late and a disaster in California, requiring a “re-do” in 1852), that same census found him in Tuolomne County, California with a new occupation: miner.5 Where the census taker recorded page after page of farmers in Orland, the Tuolomne census taker filled the occupation column with a single word: miner, miner, miner. Seth was living on his own, far from his family. The page of the census where he is listed with all those miners shows the kind of people he was meeting, hailing from not only from Tennessee, Pennsylvania, New York, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Louisiana (and a few fellow Maine men), but also men from places young Seth could have only imagined: Mexico, Norway, Scotland, Sweden, England, Ireland, The Isle of Man and India. And this was just one page.
Because of the speed with which he arrived in the gold fields and his previous occupation, we may assume he sailed to California, either all the way around the southern tip of South America or to Panama, traveling over the malarial swamps of the isthmus by foot and catching another ship on the Pacific to San Francisco.
There is no further record of Seth until the 1860 census. On June 25 of that year the census shows him rooming with L. D. Jones, also a miner, in Clear Lake, Napa County.6 One year later, on May 20, 1861, this area became part of newly formed Lake County. But Seth and his roommate would soon cause another shift in California’s county lines.
It’s common knowledge that few individuals became rich mining gold in California, but many did quite well by selling things to miners or providing services to the mining industry. Around this time, the discovery of silver in Napa County began attracting prospectors to the area. The silver did not turn out to be a big deal, but while prospecting north of Berryessa Valley in December of 1861, Seth and L. D. stumbled upon a lode of quicksilver, or mercury, in the form of cinnabar. Quicksilver was a toxic but important element used in some methods of gold mining.
The History of Napa and Lake Counties, California quotes the following account from Robert T. Montgomery:
In 18607 a company of twelve was formed in Napa City for the purpose of prospecting for mines and minerals, and two old prospectors, Seth Dunham and L. D. Jones, were sent out to examine Napa and adjacent counties. What might be found was a small matter of doubt, but the company informally organized concluded to pay a small assessment of $250 per month each, in order to find what might be the resources of the land. The prospectors were wont to bring in, about once a month, the results of their labors. The prevalent idea then was that silver abounded in the mountains of the county, and accordingly all eyes were directed to the discovery of that one metal. The company individually, and the prospectors as well, were well-nigh equally ignorant of mineralogy, and the “specimens” brought in ranged from iron pyrites to bituminous shale, all of which were supposed to contain silver. Every newspaper office and hotel bar were replete with these samples of the wealth and value of the mineral resources of the county, all of which, economically considered, were only inferior specimens of macadamizing stone—glistening, but valueless.
At last Messrs. Jones and Dunham, in their perambulations among the hills, struck a new road, then recently built between Berryessa Valley and Lower Lake, and, on ascending a hill at the head of Sulphur Canyon, just above the Elk Horn Ranch, where the soil and rock had been removed to permit the passage of teams, discovered, on the upper side of the road, at the turning point, that the rocky point, partly removed by the road-makers, was of a peculiar color and texture. Fragments broken off were very heavy and of a liver color. They were brought to town, and by the experts of those times pronounced cinnabar. And such they proved.8
The mine resulting from this find was first known by the name of the company the investors formed, XLCR, which in addition to sounding like the Latin word excelsior (excellent), also represented the names of the principal investors: Knox, Livemore, (Charles) Osborn, and Redington. By June a claim was staked, and presumably Seth and L.D. were paid some relatively small amount.9
At first called the XLCR Mine, it was later called the Redington Mine, the Knoxville Mine and the Boston Mine. It became wildly profitable, and led to further explorations in the area, resulting in an entire quicksilver mining district, with the best-known mine being at New Almaden. Knoxville, modestly named by one of the investors for himself, quickly grew from nothing into a town of 500—300 of which were employed by the mine—by 1880.10
At the time, Napa County was more about mines than wines. The influential politicians of Napa lusted after the taxes generated by the profitable Knoxville mining district that grew from Seth’s discovery. In a coup d’etat, they wrested the Knoxville area from the new and less influential Lake County in March of 1873 in exchange for a one-time payment of $3,500.11
No doubt enthusiastic with his payout and optimistic for the future, Seth married Lavina Jesse Springston in Napa County on November 17, 1864 before a local justice of the peace.12 He was 38 and she was 17, the daughter of William Springston, a farmer born about 1807 in Ohio13, and Nancy Todd, born about 1820 in Ohio.14 The Springston family had moved about quite a bit; their children were born in Ohio, Pennsylvania and Indiana; the family finally arrived in California between 1850 and 1856. Lavina herself was born February 11, 184915 and her parents seem confused by her peripatetic childhood; at various they gave her home state as Michigan, Ohio or Pennsylvania.16 She was most likely born in Michigan.
By 1870 Seth and Lavina were settled in Lower Lake in Lake County with two children, Robert, born about 1866 and Ida, who was born about 1868 and does not appear to have survived childhood.17 Seth was still working as a miner. He appears to be living on land he obtained on October 21, 1865 through the provisions of the Homestead Act of 1862. This would be the first of five land patents Seth would receive in Lake and Mendocino Counties through 1907.18
Perhaps having land made Seth feel as though he could rely on his family’s farming heritage back in Maine. He began to consider himself a farmer and made a go of it.19 We don’t know if he regretted giving up his life as a miner and prospector; he certainly seemed committed to farming.
But Seth did not seem to be a good farmer, no matter how much land he homesteaded. And he appears to have run through any money he received for his quicksilver discovery. Even as Napa and Lake Counties finally settle the dispute over the lucrative tax base of the Knoxville Mining District, he experiences financial difficulties. In 1875 he faces the humiliation of having a public notice of delinquent property taxes published in the small town.20 And there were more children. Sumner was born May 24, 1871; Ella “Minnie” on May 24, 1878; Daisy May on October 27, 1882 and Oscar Waldow on August 17, 1885.21 Still he persisted in farming; the 1800 and 1900 censuses show him as living on a farm with an occupation as a farmer, first in Middletown, Lake County and then in Long Valley, Mendocino County.
Even as recently as Seth’s time, Lake and Mendocino counties were sparsely populated. Photographs of the area from this time period show towns that look like Western movie sets, and indeed there were Native Americans living in traditional bark housing in Mendocino County during Seth’s life. Seth lived the life of a true Western pioneer.
After Seth’s death Lavina lived with her daughter Daisy May, her husband William Walker and their seven children in Santa Rosa, Sonoma County. William worked as a day laborer and Daisy May as a nurse.24 By 1930 Lavina, Daisy May, William and the two youngest children had moved back to Ukiah. Caring for Lavina must not have been easy for the Walkers; Daisy May was no longer working and the family was supported by William and their 18-year-old son Kenneth taking on odd jobs to meet the $5 rent of the house at 52 Main Street.25
Lavina died of pneumonia on October 12, 1931 in Willits, Mendocino County at the age of 82 and was buried in the Odd Fellows Cemetery there.26 Her son Sumner was probably with her when she died, as he provided the information for the death certificate. He gave her birth state as Michigan but did not know the names of her parents.
We never met Seth and Lavina. We have no family stories about them handed down, no photographs. But a look at what we can learn about them through history tells us a lot about their character, resourcefulness and sense of adventure.
Certainly Seth saw the elephant.
Seth Dunham is my great-great-grandfather
- 1850 U.S. Census for Orland, Hancock, Maine, p. 403. ⤣
- L. Donna Hoffman and Judy Sanborn, indexers, Town Records of Orland, Hancock County (privately published, 2006), p.14. ⤣
- Ibid. ⤣
- Ibid. ⤣
- 1850 U.S. Census for Township no. 5, Tuolomne County, California. ⤣
- 1860 U.S. Census for Clear Lake Township, Napa County, California, p. 23. ⤣
- John Sealey Livermore, manager of the Redington Mine, recalls the year as 1861 in Western Mining in the Twentieth Century Oral History Series, Prospector, Geologist, Public Resource Advocate: Carlin Mine Discovery, 1961, Navada Gold Rush, 1970s, a project of the Regional Oral History Office, The Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley, interviews conducted in 1992, 1997 and 1999 by Eleanor Swent and in 1997 by Maurice Fuerstenau, p. 5. Herafter referred to as Swent. ⤣
- Author not credited, History of Napa and Lake Counties, California (San Francisco: Slocum, Bowen & Co., Publishers, 1881), pp. 163-164. ⤣
- Swent, p. 5. ⤣
- History of Napa and Lake Counties, California, p. 164 ⤣
- An Act to define the Northern boundary line of Napa County, adjoining Lake and Yolo counties, approved by the California State Legislature March 8, 1871. ⤣
- Seth Dunham and Lavina Springston, Marriage License, Napa County Recorder-Clerk. ⤣
- 1860 U.S. Census, Clear Lake Township, Napa County, California, page 21. ⤣
- Little can be determined about the ancestry of Nancy Todd. There were other Todds living in the area at the time, but no connection to them can be made. It is tempting to imagine a relationship to another Todd in the area at the time: William Levi Todd. History remembers him as the creator of the Bear Flag in the revolt of the same name and as a cousin or nephew of Mary Todd, who would become the wife of Abraham Lincoln. See Warner, Barbara, “Deaths and Burials of Men Associated with the Bear Flag Revolt in California, June, 1846,” The Searcher, Southern California Genealogical Society, October 1988. ⤣
- Lavina Dunham, Death Certificate, Mendocino County Recorder-Clerk. ⤣
- Ibid., and claims Michigan: 1850 U.S. Census, Litchfield Township, Hillsdale County, Michigan; claims Ohio: 1870 U.S. Census, Lower Lake, Lake County, California, p. 13; claims Pennsylvania: 1880 U.S. Census, Middletown Precinct, Lake County, California, p. 10; claims Michigan: 1910 U.S. Census, Long Valley Township, Mendocino County, California, sheet 8, claims Michigan: 1920 U.S. Census, Santa Rosa Township, Sonoma County, California, District 153, sheet 14; claims Michigan: 1930 U.S. Census, Willits Township, Mendocino County, California, District 23-9, sheet 14A. ⤣
- 1880 Census as cited in number 14. ⤣
- Bureau of Land Management, General Land Office Records, Accession/Serial Numbers 0698-384, CACAA 016701, CACAA 015109, CACAA 031003, CACAA 014799. ⤣
- McKenney’s District Directory, 1878-79 for Yolo, Solano, Napa, Lake, Marin and Sonoma Counties lists Seth as a farmer. Presumably he had given up mining as a primary job since he was listed as such in both 1860 and 1870 Census. He is listed in 1878 as residing in Middletown, a farmer with 160 acres. ⤣
- Delinquent tax notice of the County of Lake, State of California, for the Fiscal Year 1874-75, Lakeport, Lake County, California, January 1875: DUNHAM, Seth, Cobb Mountain; personal property value- $35; possessory claim to unsurveyed land on south slope of Cobb Mountain, on old road leading from Cobb Valley to Loconoma, adjoining the lands of Springston; 160 acres. ⤣
- All birth dates: California Death Index, 1940-1997, Sate of California Department of Health Services, Center for Health Statistics and U.S. Censuses for 1880 and 1900, as cited in number 14. ⤣
- Seth Dunham, Death Certificate, Mendocino County Clerk-Recorder. Seth’s birth date is wrong on the death certificate; the person who reported the data—not a family member—mistakenly gave Lavina’s birthday as Seth’s. The hospital as place of death is from a mortuary card in the archives of the Heid-Paage Research Library in Ukiah, California. ⤣
- The death certificate states his body was released to Eversole Mortuary in Ukiah; the cemetery is unknown. ⤣
- 1920 U.S. Census as cited in number 14. ⤣
- 1930 U.S. Census as cited in number 14. That $5 in 1930 is the equivalent of about $138 in 2008 should give us an idea of the circumstances they were living in. ⤣
- Lavina Dunham, Death Certificate, Mendocino County Recorder-Clerk. ⤣